Chirality in 2D Metal-Organic Framework

Another installment in the annals of the bullying of the Shockley surface state, this time the trick isn’t exotic adatoms or massive molecular weight, just a 120° tilt of hexaazatriphenylene (HAT) ligands that converts an achiral lattice into a pair of enantiomeric 2-D metal–organic frameworks. The result: chirality-imposed scattering potentials that lift degeneracies and open ΔE ≈ 80 meV gaps in the Ag(111) two-dimensional electron gas while leaving the global periodicity intact.

Key take-aways

  • Structural chirality prints straight onto k-space
    nc-AFM resolves two co-existing enantiomers, pinwheel (PW) and “Y” phases, built from Cu–N coordination and an approximately 6° molecular cant relative to the substrate plane. STS maps acquired at 5K reveal the surface-state band dispersion reconstructed by these potentials: back-folded bands, avoided crossings and a pronounced energy gap at the new Brillouin-zone boundary.
  • No new chemistry, only symmetry
    The gaps appear without changing the molecular building blocks; tilting the HAT plane breaks mirror symmetry and generates the required chiral scattering.
  • Two tools, one story
    Electronic plane-wave expansion (EPWE) calculations feed the experimental topographies into a scattering potential and reproduce the experimental dI/dV linecuts almost quantitatively. DFT overlays the intrinsic MOF bands, showing that substrate hybridisation broadens the pyrazine and shallow-pore states but leaves the chirality-imposed gap untouched.

Why it matters

Tuning interface electronic properties usually means adding heavy metals, strain or strong correlations. Here the knob is symmetry engineering at the level of a single torsion angle, giving a gap that survives room-temperature disorder and is addressable by STM patterning. For anyone chasing chiral superconductivity, topological Bloch modes or valley-splitting without magnetic fields, that’s a tantalising new dial to turn, keeping in mind that the circumstances of its rotation are a bit rarefied, and the organics that underpin it aren’t typically associated the materials systems that carry those clusters of keywords.

Acknowledgments

The project has long roots: Sebastian synthesised the first and final HAT batch in-house back in 2019, but that’s a lot of molecules when you image them by the hundred. The low-temperature data were collected during Julian’s PhD tenure, during the LHe heyday when the coarse motor piezos had been beated back into shape (thanks Ben). Bernard, now a postdoc at LBNL, nevertheless kept pushing the modelling forward to get this across the finish line.

Tuning Interface Electronic Properties via Chiral Two-Dimensional Metal-Organic Frameworks (2025). Small Structures. https://doi.org/10.1002/sstr.202500422

Mott transition in kagome MOF

Ben & Bernard’s work on the two-dimensional kagome metal-organic framework is out this week (26 April 2024) in Nature Comms.

It was fantastic to see interesting electronic properties emerge at relatively big energy scales for this sort of work, when we were finally able to get the 2d kagome MOF composed of Cu adatoms & DCA molecules, to self-assemble on insulating hexagonal boron nitride (hBN) supported by a Cu111 metallic substrate.

We teamed up with Ben Powell’s group at UQ for the many-body expertise required to understand the tunnel junction and substrate work function dependent modulations of the electronic gap in the language of Mott physics.

Lowe, B., Field, B., Hellerstedt, J. et al. Local gate control of Mott metal-insulator transition in a 2D metal-organic framework. Nat Commun 15, 3559 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-024-47766-8

2021 AIP summer meeting

The AIP summer meeting was a hybrid event this year 6-9 Dec. ’21 with the border restrictions still in place preventing us from travelling to Brisbane.

Iolanda kindly invited me to talk about Marina’s MgPc hybridization work as well as new results of orbital tomography performed at the Australian Synchrotron (in preparation).

Ben Lowe contributed a talk to the scanning probe microscopy focus session, with an update on how we’re closing in on understanding the mechanism of formation for some unusual metal-organic products identified with ncAFM measurements.

Thanks also to Peggy Schönherr, Peggy Zhang, Peter Jacobson, and Iolanda DiBernardo for contributing talks to the SPM focus session.

Bernard Field talked about how he’s pushing forward how we can rationalise our observations of self-assembled MOF structures, stemming from our recently published experimental results that Agustin talked about in the MOF focus session.

Kagome metal-organic framework

Dhaneesh Kumar has extensively studied the on-surface properties of the DCA molecule for his PhD. After getting a good handle on just the DCA on Ag111, we started sprinkling some Cu atoms into the mix.

We observed the same honeycomb kagome structure that forms on Cu111– as seen in an ncAFM force volume shown in the right image. It has also been synthesized on graphene.

The key difference we observed on Ag111 was the Kondo effect, an STS peak at Fermi we tracked up to 150 K!

The consistent spatial distribution of this feature across the MOF was another key observation.

ncAFM force volume of DCA (structure superimposed upper right) self-assembly on Cu111 surface. dZ denotes lift of sensor away from surface for each frame.

Bernard put in the hard yards with DFT/ +U calculations in conjunction with mean-field Hubbard modelling to rationalise our experimental observations as strong Coulomb interactions between electrons within the kagome MOF.

STS maps
dI/dV STS mapping at biases indicated upper left
DCA Cu Kagome schematic
Schematic of Kondo screened spin moments within the MOF. Blender by Dhaneesh

We’re excited by the possibilities for solid-state architectures to offer further access & control of these intriguing quantum states.

Kumar, D., et. al. (2021). Manifestation of Strongly Correlated Electrons in a 2D Kagome Metal–Organic Framework. Advanced Functional Materials, 2106474. https://doi.org/10.1002/adfm.202106474

ArXiv link
FLEET blog